Prius in PA said:
I totalled my first Prius in December. The value of the car was placed at about $22,000 (It didn't come fully loaded.) My insurance company, Traveler's, decided to total it after the cost of repair exceeded 75% of the value of the car.
Most insurance companies have similar policies. If the cost of repair is 66-75% (varies per company,) of the value, they declare it a loss.
A friend of mine was pissed because his car was OBVIOUSLY totalled in an accident, and his insurance company insisted on having it repaired. The repair cost was 75.3% of the Kelley Blue Book value; and multiple safety features failed in the crash. He didn't want his car back. (Air Bags failed to deploy, antilock brakes failed to work. This was a Saturn. He researched, and it appears that the stuff failing was a one-off incident, not part of a trend.)
He would have been fine with a replacement of the same vehicle (it was only 6 months old,) but did NOT want the same car back. (Not to mention he was away from home at the time, so since it was an obvious total loss [even the insurance guy who showed up on scene said so,] he didn't bother to have it towed all the way home, but to the nearest dealer instead. Which later meant a 5 hour bus ride to get his car back.)