I have Travelers. I didn't compare prices with other companies personally but my longtime insurance agent selected them for me, so i'm confident they were the best option for me. I'm also the guy who totalled his '05 Prius in early december. Travelers was very courteous and as helpful as could be. They didn't put up any sort of fight before sending me a check for $23,000. ($1000 more than I expected to get.) Also, my insurance policy is set to renew January 10th and my premium actually went down by $15. But my agent said it just had to do with the timing and next year, it'll probably jump a bit.
As far as my experience went with them, I have no complaints.
I have travelers, or rather a subsidiary of travelers for homowner's insurance.
Well, I have them for the next few days. They are not renewing as they are pulling out of Florida for homowners' insurance.